Rivals to lovers AI roleplay: keep score, then stop

Rivals are not enemies

Rivals have no grievance. Nobody stole anything or lost a war. They simply want the same thing, and the other person is the only one good enough to stop them. That makes the tone lighter and quicker than enemies to lovers: more bickering, more showing off, more pride.

The heart of the trope is that a rival notices you more closely than anyone. To beat you, they have studied you. Mika has memorised your settings and stays up reviewing your replays "to find your weaknesses". That attention is already a kind of intimacy; neither of you has admitted it yet.

Put the competition on screen

Talking about being rivals gets dull quickly. Compete. Challenge them to a one-on-one, a bet, a race to the top of the leaderboard, and play it out move by move. The AI is good at narrating a contest if you give it the rules and your move: "I take the long angle and wait. Your turn."

Keep score out loud. Ask the character to track it, or announce it yourself after every round. A running score gives the story a spine and lets you call back to old wins: "That makes it eleven to ten, rookie."

Lose sometimes

If you win every contest, your rival becomes a sore loser rather than a worthy one. Take some losses with grace, or with fury. The turn of the trope often lives in a loss: the first time one of you throws a match for the other, or the first time losing to them stings less than beating anyone else.

• The challenge: a prize only one of you can have.
• Proof of equality: each wins a round that matters.
• The partnership forced on you by a coach, an agency, a manager.
• The tell: care disguised as competition ("I covered you because I want to beat you myself").
• The decision: the prize matters less than the person.

Rivals ready to play

Mika Tachibana is the star entry player on a pro tactical-shooter team, and the coach will name one of you captain before the playoffs. You are an hour late to a scrim; she is the only one still up, with your favourite energy drink waiting beside her chair ("I bought two by accident"). She calls you rookie and denies every kind thing she does.

Daichi Kurose, hero name Flashpoint, is ranked eighth. You are seventh. After a rescue went wrong because you were competing, the agency made you permanent partners, and he has been pacing the rooftop for an hour scorching the water tower. Ren Kurosawa is the league's coldest striker, and your first report as the club's new analyst said defenders can read his runs. He is waiting under the floodlights for you to prove it.

Opening lines

• To Mika: *cracks my knuckles and sits down* "One-on-one, first to five. Loser buys breakfast and admits who waited up for who."
• To Daichi: *steps up to the roof edge beside him* "Score from the last three rescues: Seventh two, Eighth one. Try to keep up tonight, partner."
• To Ren: *rolls the ball back to his feet* "You drift left before you check your shoulder. Do it again and I will call it before you move."

Writing your own rival

Pick the prize, the arena and a scoring system first. Then give the rival a skill that is genuinely better than yours, a habit of denial for every kind act, and one weakness only you have spotted. The greeting should drop you into a contest already running. Make your own; superhero and anime settings both suit this trope.

Questions people ask